Dublin Core
Title
Kat Tudor, Bob Tudor, Encho Avramov, Holly Parker, Lindsay Rat, and Adam Conard
Homage to Guernica
2004
Gift to Colorado College by Smoke Brush Gallery
Paint on Board
Cossitt Amphitheater
Written by Claire Schwartz, Class of ‘23
Subject
Homage to Guernica is a powerful community effort that uses art as activism and outlet. While it was gifted to Colorado College to include our campus community in their emotions and protest against the Iraq war. It raises questions of whether reproducing the artwork of a controversial artist like Picasso is ethical.
Does the anti-war message outweigh the harm caused by Picasso?
Description
This mural, Homage to Guernica, was completed in 2004 at the Smokebrush Gallery in Colorado Springs. Kat Tudor, Bob Tudor, Encho Avramov, Holly Parker, Lindsay Rat, and Adam Conard created it as a team. Later, the artists gifted it to the school. The mural is an altered copy of Picasso’s 1937 mural Guernica which depicts the bombing of the Basque city of Guernica during the Spanish Civil War. Picasso created the original Guernica as part of the Spanish Pavilion for the 1937 Paris World’s Fair.
Guernica by Picasso is one of the most famous anti-war artworks ever made. In 2003 when Colin Powell made a speech defending the Iraq War at the United Nations, the United Nations covered the tapestry replica of Guernica. Outraged at the violence and US involvement of the Iraq War, Encho Avramov rallied a team at Smokebrush Gallery to create Homage to Guernica in protest.
While all that stands today is the reversed background mural, the original piece had many mobile cutouts. These cutouts depicted the screaming mother, the horse, and the hand with the light from the original Guernica. They also used the American flag and made a direct statement against the US involvement in Iraq. To Encho, these were the most powerful parts of the artwork. However, in the almost 20 years following, the cutouts have disappeared or been destroyed, along with the original anti-war message.
The team of artists created Homage to express their anger and sorrow in community with each other, using art as activism and outlet. By later gifting the piece to CC, they included our campus community in their emotions and protest. Yet, with the destruction of the most powerful anti-war parts of the artwork, they also destroyed the original message and community connection. I hope to remind our community of the horrors of war, and the importance of art as collective activism.
While this piece was a powerful communal effort, it also was a reproduction of an artwork by a very controversial artist, Picasso. While Picasso was not as much a divisive figure in 2004, his abuse of women and use of African Art have become topics of debate over the last 10 years, especially in the wake of the ‘Me Too’ and ‘Black Lives Matter’ movements. Knowing the harm Picasso caused, I am left to question whether reproducing his artwork is the most ethical decision. Does the anti-war, communal message outweigh the abuse of Picasso? Does the message of the piece outweigh the harm caused by Picasso? We can only answer that question for ourselves. As this piece demonstrates, art is political. Therefore, it can be a means to express our voices and opinions, both collectively and individually, and spark community conversation.
Source
Works Cited:
Cantelupe, Eugene B. “Picasso’s Guernica.” Art Journal 31, no. 1 (1971): 18–21. https://doi.org/10.2307/775628.
https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2003/03/01/why-did-the-united-nations-cover-up-picassos-guernica