Berkey Context for Part 3 (750-1000): Sunni and Shi'i Islam in political context and Caliphs

Dublin Core

Title

Berkey Context for Part 3 (750-1000): Sunni and Shi'i Islam in political context and Caliphs

Subject

Sunni and Shi'i Identity forming

Description

A long explanation of the power struggle between Sunni and Shi'i Islam that defined the political sphere after the Abbasid Revolution.

Creator

​​Jonathan Berkey

Source

The Formation of Islam: Religion and Society in the Near East, 600-1800, section 3, chapter 13, page 125

Publisher

Cambridge University Press

Date

First published 2003
Discussions of 750-1000

Language

English

Text Item Type Metadata

Text

But the relationship of political to religious authority was a matter of considerable contention and evolution during the first centuries of the Abbasid rule. These issues were central to the distinction between what came to be called Sunni and Shi'i Islam, a distinction which was clarified in precisely this period. It would be anachronistic, therefore, to expect a clear articulation of the differences at the beginning of the Abbasid era, but with the advantage of hindsight, the issue can be expressed as a contradiction. In Sunni Islam, there is no necessary connection between political and religious authority: prophethood as a legislative project came to an end with Mohammed, and what religious authority remained devolved upon the ulama as expressed through their consensus. (In fact, of course, the matter is rather more complicated than this concise description would suggest, and its ambiguities, and the course of their development, will form the subject of much that follows.) In practice, however, the caliphs (and later rulers with other titles) addressed themselves to and intervened in religious issues both directly and indirectly. In Shi'i Islam, by contrast, religious authority is in theory closely connected to political authority, both being vested in the person of the Imam. In practice, however, while there was nothing to prevent Shi'is giving substance to their Imams' claims to religious authority proved completely chimerical (at least until the rise of the Fatimids in the tenth century).

Original Format

Book

Citation

​​Jonathan Berkey , “Berkey Context for Part 3 (750-1000): Sunni and Shi'i Islam in political context and Caliphs,” Denney, accessed November 16, 2026, https://coloradocollege.website/sdenney/items/show/25.